On merit

Some Reflections on the Relationship between Merit and Altruism

Abstract

Who truly deserves more? Should the market be the sole arbiter of merit? The ongoing debate on meritocracy, particularly ignited by Michael Sandel’s The Tyranny of Merit, compels us to reflect on which forms of merit society should acknowledge and reward. Individual success is rarely the sole outcome of a single person’s effort; rather, it emerges from a complex interplay of people and circumstances. While it is legitimate to reward individual commitment and talent, it may be even more crucial to recognize and reward those who direct their efforts toward others, acknowledging them as individuals worthy of care and attention due to their inherent dignity. The inherent relational nature of merit suggests a necessary redefinition of social recognition. This redefined framework should prioritize and reward solidarity, trust, the ability to inspire groups and collaborators, service and generosity, and the care shown toward those in difficulty.